The Scottish Legends
In 2001, Arthur Herman wrote a delightful book called How the Scots Invented the Modern World: The True Story of How Western Europe s Poorest Nation Created Our World and Everything in It. Face it: Scottish people believe this is all true. And so it goes with the Templar myths of Scotland. Many legends about Scotland and the Templars exist, and certain folks believe every single one of them.
The legend goes that the Templar fleet set sail from La Rochelle and made its way around England and to the coast of Scotland, near Argyll, by some accounts. The Templars, now under threat of excommunication by the pope, needed asylum, and Scotland was the logical choice. King Robert I (“The Bruce”) was at war with England and had himself been excommunicated by the pope for murdering a Scottish nobleman in 1306. England sought to absorb Scotland, while Robert the Bruce was determined it be an independent nation.
You say Sinclair, I say Saint-Clair
The common family name that runs throughout the Scottish Templar theories is Saint-Clair, or Sinclair, and it gets very confusing, mostly because so many of them are named William or Henry (showing an almost criminal lack of family imagination). Originally from Normandy, they have been a powerful and influential clan throughout Scottish history—even Shakespeare's Macbeth features the Earl of Caithness, a Saint-Clair, as a powerful Scottish laird. Here's the breakdown:
● William "The Seemly" Saint-Clair was granted the area around Roslin in 1057.
● Henri de Saint-Clair, First Earl of Roslin, fought in the first Crusade with Godfroi de Bouillon, and with Hughes de Payens, the founder of the Knights Templar. It is also claimed that Hughes visited Roslin, Scotland, in 1126, and was given the land to build the first Templar preceptory outside of the Holy Land at Ballontrodoch, known later as Temple.
● Sir William Saint-Clair (1260-1303) was the first Baron of Roslin.
● Sir Henry Saint-Clair (?—1330), was Sir William's eldest son, and a friend of Robert the Bruce.
● Another Sir William Saint-Clair (1300—1330) was Henry's son, who was slain by the Moors in Spain in 1330 as he tried to head for the Holy Land to bury the heart of Robert the Bruce. This Sir William was married to Isabel, daughter of Malise, Earl of Strathearn, Caithness, and Orkney. It is this William Saint-Clair who is alleged by some to have been the last Grand Master of the Templars. But if he had actually been a member of the order, why did he and his brother Henry both testify in a Scottish trial against the Templars that they had heard suspicious rumors about the order's "secret" initiations?
● William and Isabel's son was another Henry Saint-Clair, First Earl of Orkney (1345-1400). It was this Henry who has been claimed to have explored Greenland and North America with the Venetian Antonio Zeno (see "Henry Saint-Clair and the Zeno Narrative," later in this chapter). He is sometimes referred to as Prince Henry I of Orkney, and is actually believed to have died in 1400 fighting the English, and not in Greenland as has been suggested.
● His son, Henry Saint-Clair, Second Earl of Orkney (1375-1422), served as Lord High Admiral, and later, Lord Chancellor, of Scotland. For a time, he was protector of the young James Stuart, who would become King James I of Scotland. It is through this connection that a supposed Templar and Masonic link is made to the Stuart line of kings and pretenders.
● Henry's son, William Saint-Clair, First Earl of Caithness, 3rd Earl of Orkney, and Baron of Roslin (1404-1480), was the builder of Rosslyn Chapel, which began in 1440.
● A later William Saint-Clair of Roslin is claimed in 1602 as the "hereditary Grand Master Mason of Scotland" by several stonemason lodges. It turns out he wasn't the best role model — he seems to have almost immediately skipped off to Ireland over an alleged affair with a local milkmaid. His son, yet another William Saint-Clair, was claimed by the stonemasons again almost 30 years later as their hereditary Grand Master, in a bit of power politics. The Masons wanted a patron with royal favor, but King Charles I declined to officially name Saint-Clair as the protector of their guild.
● And, just to add to the confusion, in 1736 one more William Saint-Clair of Roslin (17001778) was named as the first Grand Master of the Freemasons' new Grand Lodge of Scotland. He accepted the honor, and then signed away any hereditary claim to the position in favor of elected officers. Nobody gets out of a job that easily. They turned around and elected him to the position for life. Interestingly, he wasn't a Freemason when he was contacted with the offer and had to be initiated as a Mason before he could accept the job. When he died, he was the last Saint-Clair to be buried in the subterranean vaults of the chapel — so far.
Battle of Bannockburn
The legendary tale of the Templars in Scotland always leads to the story of the Battle of Bannockburn in 1314. Robert the Bruce’s troops met King Edward Il’s advancing English forces at a stream called Bannock Burn in what was the decisive victory for the Scots in their first war of independence. The Bruce’s Scottish forces of less than 9,000 men, armed mostly with spears, were heavily outnumbered by Edward’s 2,000 men on horse and 16,000 foot soldiers. The legend goes that at a crucial point in the battle, out of the woods rode a fierce contingent of mounted Knights Templar, dressed in white, who turned the battle in Robert the Bruce’s favor and forced Edward and his troops to flee back to England. And there was much rejoicing.
It is a romantic tale, but a highly unlikely one. The Templars had not been on a major field of battle since the fall of Acre in the Holy Land in 1291; they had essentially lived quiet lives across Europe until their arrests in 1307.
Even if you believe that large numbers of Templars really were hiding out in Scotland, the battle-trained fighting men from the Holy Land were, frankly, a little long in the tooth after more than 20 years of inactivity to be donning their chainmail and riding into battle.
Of course, one variation on the tale includes the use of the Ark of the Covenant as a weapon of mass destruction. This particular legend claims that the aging knights used the secret, sacred, and divine powers contained in the Ark, which they had smuggled from Jerusalem to France, and then to Scotland, to defeat the overwhelming English army.
An account written shortly after the battle really identified these mysterious Scottish troops who came out of the woods as something of a rabble of untrained and unarmed scavengers, and not a highly trained and disciplined legendary army of warrior monks. Robert the Bruce was a master of guerilla tactics in the field and had told this motley collection of miscreants to assemble in a clearing behind the woods, hidden from the view of the English troops. They fashioned spears and made flagpoles and pennants to look like fresh troops. Then at the moment when the English were trapped between advancing Scots forces, the woods, and a creek, Robert called for this group to run screaming out of the woods to give the illusion of a flanking attack.
The trick worked, and the English fled the battlefield.
Still, believers in the Templars’ exploits at Bannockburn have their own explanation. The Templars were hiding in secret, fearing for their lives that unsympathetic Catholics would rat them out. Robert the Bruce was excommunicated and was a sharp enough leader to gratefully accept any military help he could get in his fight for Scottish independence. He was also sharp enough to know that, after the war, he would need to make nice with the Church again, so it would be pretty foolish to publicly acknowledge that he’d given safe haven to the dissolved Templars. Therefore, after the war was over, using the talents of his friend Sir William Saint-Clair (1300-1330), Freemasonry was created in Scotland as a society for the Templars to safely provide cover for their mutual protection. That’s the legend, anyway.
In 2001, Arthur Herman wrote a delightful book called How the Scots Invented the Modern World: The True Story of How Western Europe s Poorest Nation Created Our World and Everything in It. Face it: Scottish people believe this is all true. And so it goes with the Templar myths of Scotland. Many legends about Scotland and the Templars exist, and certain folks believe every single one of them.
The legend goes that the Templar fleet set sail from La Rochelle and made its way around England and to the coast of Scotland, near Argyll, by some accounts. The Templars, now under threat of excommunication by the pope, needed asylum, and Scotland was the logical choice. King Robert I (“The Bruce”) was at war with England and had himself been excommunicated by the pope for murdering a Scottish nobleman in 1306. England sought to absorb Scotland, while Robert the Bruce was determined it be an independent nation.
You say Sinclair, I say Saint-Clair
The common family name that runs throughout the Scottish Templar theories is Saint-Clair, or Sinclair, and it gets very confusing, mostly because so many of them are named William or Henry (showing an almost criminal lack of family imagination). Originally from Normandy, they have been a powerful and influential clan throughout Scottish history—even Shakespeare's Macbeth features the Earl of Caithness, a Saint-Clair, as a powerful Scottish laird. Here's the breakdown:
● William "The Seemly" Saint-Clair was granted the area around Roslin in 1057.
● Henri de Saint-Clair, First Earl of Roslin, fought in the first Crusade with Godfroi de Bouillon, and with Hughes de Payens, the founder of the Knights Templar. It is also claimed that Hughes visited Roslin, Scotland, in 1126, and was given the land to build the first Templar preceptory outside of the Holy Land at Ballontrodoch, known later as Temple.
● Sir William Saint-Clair (1260-1303) was the first Baron of Roslin.
● Sir Henry Saint-Clair (?—1330), was Sir William's eldest son, and a friend of Robert the Bruce.
● Another Sir William Saint-Clair (1300—1330) was Henry's son, who was slain by the Moors in Spain in 1330 as he tried to head for the Holy Land to bury the heart of Robert the Bruce. This Sir William was married to Isabel, daughter of Malise, Earl of Strathearn, Caithness, and Orkney. It is this William Saint-Clair who is alleged by some to have been the last Grand Master of the Templars. But if he had actually been a member of the order, why did he and his brother Henry both testify in a Scottish trial against the Templars that they had heard suspicious rumors about the order's "secret" initiations?
● William and Isabel's son was another Henry Saint-Clair, First Earl of Orkney (1345-1400). It was this Henry who has been claimed to have explored Greenland and North America with the Venetian Antonio Zeno (see "Henry Saint-Clair and the Zeno Narrative," later in this chapter). He is sometimes referred to as Prince Henry I of Orkney, and is actually believed to have died in 1400 fighting the English, and not in Greenland as has been suggested.
● His son, Henry Saint-Clair, Second Earl of Orkney (1375-1422), served as Lord High Admiral, and later, Lord Chancellor, of Scotland. For a time, he was protector of the young James Stuart, who would become King James I of Scotland. It is through this connection that a supposed Templar and Masonic link is made to the Stuart line of kings and pretenders.
● Henry's son, William Saint-Clair, First Earl of Caithness, 3rd Earl of Orkney, and Baron of Roslin (1404-1480), was the builder of Rosslyn Chapel, which began in 1440.
● A later William Saint-Clair of Roslin is claimed in 1602 as the "hereditary Grand Master Mason of Scotland" by several stonemason lodges. It turns out he wasn't the best role model — he seems to have almost immediately skipped off to Ireland over an alleged affair with a local milkmaid. His son, yet another William Saint-Clair, was claimed by the stonemasons again almost 30 years later as their hereditary Grand Master, in a bit of power politics. The Masons wanted a patron with royal favor, but King Charles I declined to officially name Saint-Clair as the protector of their guild.
● And, just to add to the confusion, in 1736 one more William Saint-Clair of Roslin (17001778) was named as the first Grand Master of the Freemasons' new Grand Lodge of Scotland. He accepted the honor, and then signed away any hereditary claim to the position in favor of elected officers. Nobody gets out of a job that easily. They turned around and elected him to the position for life. Interestingly, he wasn't a Freemason when he was contacted with the offer and had to be initiated as a Mason before he could accept the job. When he died, he was the last Saint-Clair to be buried in the subterranean vaults of the chapel — so far.
Battle of Bannockburn
The legendary tale of the Templars in Scotland always leads to the story of the Battle of Bannockburn in 1314. Robert the Bruce’s troops met King Edward Il’s advancing English forces at a stream called Bannock Burn in what was the decisive victory for the Scots in their first war of independence. The Bruce’s Scottish forces of less than 9,000 men, armed mostly with spears, were heavily outnumbered by Edward’s 2,000 men on horse and 16,000 foot soldiers. The legend goes that at a crucial point in the battle, out of the woods rode a fierce contingent of mounted Knights Templar, dressed in white, who turned the battle in Robert the Bruce’s favor and forced Edward and his troops to flee back to England. And there was much rejoicing.
It is a romantic tale, but a highly unlikely one. The Templars had not been on a major field of battle since the fall of Acre in the Holy Land in 1291; they had essentially lived quiet lives across Europe until their arrests in 1307.
Even if you believe that large numbers of Templars really were hiding out in Scotland, the battle-trained fighting men from the Holy Land were, frankly, a little long in the tooth after more than 20 years of inactivity to be donning their chainmail and riding into battle.
Of course, one variation on the tale includes the use of the Ark of the Covenant as a weapon of mass destruction. This particular legend claims that the aging knights used the secret, sacred, and divine powers contained in the Ark, which they had smuggled from Jerusalem to France, and then to Scotland, to defeat the overwhelming English army.
An account written shortly after the battle really identified these mysterious Scottish troops who came out of the woods as something of a rabble of untrained and unarmed scavengers, and not a highly trained and disciplined legendary army of warrior monks. Robert the Bruce was a master of guerilla tactics in the field and had told this motley collection of miscreants to assemble in a clearing behind the woods, hidden from the view of the English troops. They fashioned spears and made flagpoles and pennants to look like fresh troops. Then at the moment when the English were trapped between advancing Scots forces, the woods, and a creek, Robert called for this group to run screaming out of the woods to give the illusion of a flanking attack.
The trick worked, and the English fled the battlefield.
Still, believers in the Templars’ exploits at Bannockburn have their own explanation. The Templars were hiding in secret, fearing for their lives that unsympathetic Catholics would rat them out. Robert the Bruce was excommunicated and was a sharp enough leader to gratefully accept any military help he could get in his fight for Scottish independence. He was also sharp enough to know that, after the war, he would need to make nice with the Church again, so it would be pretty foolish to publicly acknowledge that he’d given safe haven to the dissolved Templars. Therefore, after the war was over, using the talents of his friend Sir William Saint-Clair (1300-1330), Freemasonry was created in Scotland as a society for the Templars to safely provide cover for their mutual protection. That’s the legend, anyway.
Comment